Each criterion is graded out of 20. Essay grade is the sum of points earned on individual criteria.

1. This essay demonstrates a clearly articulated thesis adapted to the depth of the subject matter and connected to the content or method of this course

____________

2. The thesis articulated has been adequately defended using the author’s creativity ____________

3. The essay appropriately considers viewpoints other than the author’s when arguing on behalf of the thesis

_____________

4. The grammar, spelling, paragraph structure, organization, clarity, and content is of high quality

_______________

5. The essay contains a combination of quotations, paraphrasing, citations, etc. such that it is evident that the author understands the nuances of the problem considered and the relevant application of other philosophers’ ideas

___________________